Field of Science

The science of puns

Puns are jokes involving ambiguous words. Some are hilarious. Some are only groan-worthy. (If anyone wants to argue the first one isn't a pun, comment away.)

Wait -- aren't all words ambiguous?
The thing about puns that pops out at me is that pretty much every word is ambigous. My parade-case for an unambiguous word -- really a phrase -- is George Washington. But, of course, more than one person has been named "George Washington," so even that one is ambiguous. In any case, the vast majority of words are ambiguous -- including the words word and pun.

Most of the time we don't even notice that a words is ambiguous, because our brains quickly select the contextually-appropriate meaning. For a pun, this selection has to fail in some way, since we remain aware of the multiple appropriate meanings.

Studying puns
As someone who studies how context is used to understand language, this makes puns and other homophones interesting. I'm also currently starting a new EEG experiment looking at the processing of ambiguous words in folks on the autism spectrum. But one question that I'm interested in is why some puns are funnier than others.

As a first step in that work, I need a bunch of puns ranked for how funny they are. There are website out there that have these types of rankings, but they don't use the sorts of controls that any peer-reviewed journal will demand. So I am running a rank-that-pun "experiment" at GamesWithWords.org called Puntastic! It goes without saying that once I've got enough puns rated, I'll post what I learn here (including what were the funniest and the worst puns). This make take a few months, though, as I'm getting ratings for over 500 puns.

(picture above isn't just a picture -- it's a t-shirt)

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

I clicked on I don't understand on the first pun (it relied on a nonsense word) and I got kicked out.

Huh?

Anonymous said...

The more I think about it the more I think the offending sentence was the first one from the he/she experiment.

Dick Margulis said...

What anonymous said, on both occasions. (Tried twice.)

Psi Wavefunction said...

What anon said -- thirded.

coglanglab said...

Many thanks. Yesterday I fixed some spelling errors in a few of the puns (they were pulled for a user-contributed website, so there are a lot of spelling errors and I keep finding new ones) and in the process broke the Flash file.

It should work now.

coglanglab said...

PS -- For those of you who tried the experiment when it was broken: you may need to empty your browser's cache before trying the experiment again. Some browsers helpfully store files so you don't have to download them again, so it'll just give you the old broken file again. In any case, this is what happened to me with Safari when I was testing the fixed version. For Safari "empty cache" is in the Safari menu.

literalminded said...

Arnold Zwicky wrote a paper about puns back in the 1980s, I think. You might check with him to see if it's one of those that he's digitally scanned and made available.

josh said...

Literal-minded: Thanks for the suggestion. I'm just starting to work through the pun literature, and I haven't gotten to that one yet.